New search
download case
  • Overview
  • Teaching Notes
  • Answer Key
  • Supplemental Materials
  • Videos
  • Comments/Replies

Cross-Dressing or Crossing-Over?

Sex Testing of Women Athletes



Co Authors:

Maureen Knabb
Department of Biology
West Chester University of Pennsylvania
mknabb@wcupa.edu

Joan Sharp
Department of Biological Sciences
Simon Fraser University
jsharp@sfu.ca

Abstract:

In this “clicker case,” students learn about sex determination, meiosis, and chromosomal “crossing over” through the story of Santhi Soundararajan, an athlete from Kathakkurichi, India, who was stripped of a medal at the 2006 Asian Games after failing to pass a sex test. The case is called a clicker case because it combines the use of student personal response systems (clickers) with case teaching methods and formats. The case itself is a PowerPoint presentation (~2 MB) shown in class that is punctuated by questions students respond to using their clickers. It can be adapted for use without these technologies. Developed for an introductory biology class for both majors and non-majors, the case could also be used in an anatomy and physiology course or an endocrinology course.

Objectives:
  • Explain the basis of sex determination in mammals.
  • Describe the sources of variation in daughter cells produced by meiosis.
  • Understand the role of the SRY gene in the determination of a human embryo as male.
  • Explain how human sex reversal (XX/SRY+ male; XY/SRY- female) may take place.
Keywords: Crossing-over; gametogenesis; gender testing; sex testing; meiosis; cell division; karyotype; sex determination; sex reversal; SRY gene; Santhi Soundararajan
Topical Area: Legal issues, Social issues
Educational Level: Undergraduate lower division
Formats: PDF
Type/Method: Clicker, Interrupted, Dilemma/Decision
Language: English
Subject Headings: Biology (General)   Cell Biology   Physiology   Sports Science  
Date Posted: 09/09/08
Date Modified:
Copyright: Copyright held by the National Center for Case Study Teaching in Science, University at Buffalo, State University of New York. Please see our usage guidelines, which outline our policy concerning permissible reproduction of this work.

Teaching Notes


Case teaching notes are password-protected and access to them is limited to paid subscribed instructors. To become a paid subscriber, begin the process by registering here.

Teaching notes are intended to help teachers select and adopt a case. They typically include a summary of the case, teaching objectives, information about the intended audience, details about how the case may be taught, and a list of references and resources.

  Download Teaching Notes

Answer Key


Answer keys for the cases in our collection are password-protected and access to them is limited to paid subscribed instructors. To become a paid subscriber, begin the process by registering here.


  Get Answer Key

Supplemental Materials


The following Supplemental(s) are recommended for use in association with this case study.

  Click and Learn Activity: Gender Testing of Athletes hhmi/
Is it a boy or a girl? In this lecture, David C. Page, MD, looks at how we define male and female and summarizes the development of human sex characteristics. He then explains the role of the sex chromosomes, X and Y, and, in particular, the SRY gene. Running time: 58:51 min. Produced by: HHMI BioInteractive.
   Lecture: Deciphering the Language of Sex hhmi/
Is it a boy or a girl? In this lecture, David C. Page, MD, looks at how we define male and female and summarizes the development of human sex characteristics. He then explains the role of the sex chromosomes, X and Y, and, in particular, the SRY gene. Running time: 58:51 min. Produced by: HHMI BioInteractive.

Videos

The following video(s) are recommended for use in association with this case study.

  Meiosis (Animation) hhmi/
Meiosis, the form of cell division unique to egg and sperm production, sets the stage for sex determination by creating sperm that carry either an X or a Y sex chromosome. But what is it about the X or Y that determines sex? The animation presented in this video connects meiosis and sex determination. Running time: 5:53 min. Produced by: HHMI BioInteractive.

  The Y Chromosome (Animation) hhmi/
The Y chromosome has been likened to a hall of mirrors because its sequence contains many sections that appear to be palindromes. These palindromes provide a clue to some interesting events that may have occurred during the course of the chromosome's evolution. Running time: 2:46 min. Produced by: HHMI BioInteractive.

This a great case, and can be made even stronger with two modifications:
  1. The "emotional" impact can be substantially strengthened by at intervals asking students this clicker question: "What do you think Santhi is?" (A: Boy, B: Girl, C: Don't Know) and then at the very end I tell them they have to decide one gender or the other, there is no "don't know" option.
  2. Tthe recent updates of her story should be added. Santhi was fired from her coaching job and found work in a brick-making factory, very hard work for low pay. Reasons for firing are unclear but probably related to her gender controversy. And even more recently, this news story: "BANGALORE: Santhi Soundarajan, who was stripped of her 800m silver medal after failing a gender test at the 2006 Doha Asian Games and was later forced to work as a labourer in a brick kiln, has finally been given the opportunity to realise her dream of becoming a qualified athletics coach. The government has removed its rider of ascertaining her gender before allowing her to pursue the diploma course in Patiala." http://articles.timesofindia.indiatimes.com/2013-03-29/others/38125168_1_nis-patiala-gender-test-santhi-soundarajan.



Eric Ribbens
Biological Sciences
Western Illinois University
Macomb, IL
E-Ribbens@wiu.edu
6/2/2013



Name:
Email:
Department:
Institution:
City State:
Comments:
security code
Enter Security Code: